11 games into their rookie years, it's a decent time to reflect on theLions draft class of 2009, and to look forward to the 2010 draft.
1. Matt Stafford- Although he has struggled with his interceptions, Stafford's overall game has been well worth the investment at #1 overall. Stafford has only been sacked 21 times in 10 games, which is over a 50 percent improvement from the Lions QB's last year. The offensive line is mostly intact. He must improve his ratings, but the Lions need to get him some more help before that is going to happen.
2. Brandon Pettigrew- His rookie season is over, due to a knee injury on Thanksgiving. His play has been up and down, but does show first round ability. Has had an issue with dropping passes, but it doesn't seem to be a major issue. He's a solid player, but he needs to get back healthy.
3. Louis Delmas- His play has been spectacular at times, but he's had some struggles. He's been fined four times in his rookie year, which is an astounding rate. He might think it's the price of doing business, and he's right to some extent, but he needs to corral his play as he deals with the issues that has caused the fines. He could be a future pro bowler if he does.
4. Deandre Levy- He's been a nice surprise. It was hard to picture him in the middle, where he was started in mini-camp, but he's turned into one of the Lions most versatile performers in recent memory in a hurry. He has played all three LB positions very well. The only question, is who is this year's Levy in this draft. Two more, and the Lions will be set at LB for a long time.
5. Derrick Williams- He looked to have explosion and playmaking skills at Penn State, but where did it go? Red flags should have gone up when he did not run well at the combine, although he ran much better at his pro day, and was excused for having the flu at the combine. The Lions missed this pick at the onset. Three other players would have made more sense here, such as Deon Butler, Mike Wallace, and Johnny Knox. All three were available, and ran better. All three have done much better as pros. Williams must develop.
6. Sammie Hill- For being a developmental type prospect, Hill has played nicely and has started most of the season. He had injury problems week 4 thru 8, but his return has improved the Lions run defense noticeably. He's a terrific value for a fourth round pick.
7. Aaron Brown- Has provided the team with a much needed boost in the speed department, and has improved recently with his play in the return game. He is what he is, a third down back, but he must improve his pass blocking skills. It's also important to note that the Lions had him lined up at split end on Thanksgiving day, where he had shown his ability to make plays with a 26 yard screen against the Browns. Is his future at WR?
8. Lydon Murtha- Has moved onto Miami as a left guard, which is a shame. I thought he'd be a perfect developmental left tackle on the cheap. Besides Williams, this is the biggest blunder by the Lions in this otherwise impressive draft.
9. Zack Follett- Has hit his mark as a special teams ace, and has made an impact. If this is all he is, it's still a worth while pick, but he also has value as a backup LBer.
10. Dan Gronkowski- Finally up with Pettigrew's injury, he showed some flashes in preseason. He was also a nice pick, and adds value with his speed/size.
Looking forward, as of December 6th, the Lions are in the fourth spot. It might be too low to draft one of the two DT's (McCoy and Suh), but that will depend on the QB. Right now the first three picks belong to Tampa Bay, Cleveland, and St. Louis.
Saturday, December 5, 2009
Thursday, August 6, 2009
Training camp AM practice, 8/06/09...
Well, I was at today's practice, I took my son and nephew. The biggest issue is that so many key players were out, but Coach Schwartz poo-pooed it to me when he walked by. Said most were dings, he wasn't worried at all. I asked him who #46 was, since he wasn't in the program or had his name on the jersey, he told me it was Carson Butler, who played at UM. Then he asked me if I was a Michigan fan, and I told him I was more of a Lion fan. While talking to me he was giving the boys autographs, and I was very appreciative for the information, which has obviously been released. Practice was fast paced, and different then I had ever seen. Last year, I had seen hitting, which I talked about, but this year, the players are flat out at game speed. The hitting going on is quite crazy for practice, but enjoyable. Matt Stafford was much sharper in my mind than Culpepper, who has a habit of holding on too long, but the offense looks good. Stafford struggled a bit in the red zone drills. I love how Stafford finishes every play like Favre, even runs, and he hides the ball very well in play action. Stanton also looked pretty sharp. Other players that stood out included Aaron Brown, who's built alot like Robert Smith; with his thin legs that are built for speed. Dan Gronkowski and Butler looked sharp, as the Lions QB's used the TE's quite often. Some guy, #81 I think, made some really spectacular grabs, and was kind enough to give the boys autographs, as was Kevin Smith, who does look thicker in the legs than last year.
Sunday, May 24, 2009
Lions 2010 Free agents...
With the help of Netrat's excellent page on the Lions contract situation, looking at the Lions free agent situation going into 2010, and the Lions surprisingly have most of their starters under contract for 2010, with just a few (Culpepper, Foote, Raiola, Loper, and Henry) exceptions. The Lions have already expressed interest in resigning Raiola, and will probably look at Loper hard as a long-term contract also. Culpepper and Foote could very well be temporary fill-ins while waiting for rookies at both spots, and the Lions will definitely need to hit the cornerback spot hard in the next off-season. What Netrat is missing from his spreadsheet is ages, and that would help guage what the plans are.
Monday, April 13, 2009
Reading the tea leaves...
It's time to start separating the lies from the truth. I'm going to give my impression on what I think the teams are going to do. This isn't really a mock draft per se.
1. Lions- Matt Stafford, QB (backup plan- Jason Smith, OL)- I'm 90% convinced that Stafford will be signed and selected for the pick. The Lions aren't saying much, but the fact they haven't signed a backup QB speaks volumes right now.
2. Rams- Jason Smith, OL (backup plan- Eugene Monroe, OL)- I'm 100% convinced they will select a tackle, they don't have a good backup plan if they don't. They've made their plans obvious by releasing Pace, and not signing a LT.
3. Chiefs- Eugene Monroe, OL (backup plan- Aaron Curry, LB)- I'm not 100% sure about this, but the recent signing of Zach Thomas is a head scratcher. They could move Albert to LG, and reunite the Virginia left side. Scott Pioli does have connections with Virginia HC Al Groh, and would feel safe with this selection.
4. Seahawks- Aaron Curry, LB (backup plan- Mark Sanchez, QB)- If he's there, I believe the Seahawks are lying in wait to take Curry. Otherwise, this is a QB landing spot.
5. Browns- Michael Crabtree, WR (backup plan- Brian Orapko, DE)- I think the Browns absolutely feel a need to select Crabtree. I also think they could still trade Edwards for picks. They have a pass rushing need also.
6. Bengals- Andre Smith, OL (backup plan- Jeremy Maclin, WR)- The thing about the Bengals is they usually draft linemen high, and they don't scout well.
7. Raiders- Darrius Heyward-Bey, WR (backup plan- Jeremy Maclin, WR)- The Raiders won't select a player like Crabtree they don't have a time for, but they will select a player like DHB that they have top times on. I'm almost ready to call this a lock.
8. Jaguars- Jeremy Maclin, WR (backup plan- Michael Oher, OL)- The Jaguars have had issues with the WR position for a long time now, and this has become the achilles heel of their team. I don't see many room for trades yet, but anything can happen.
9. Packers- BJ Raji, DT (backup plan- Brian Orakpo, DE)- One thing about the current Packers administration is that they will draft a ton of defensive linemen year in and year out. Other wise, they don't show their cards, and play it close to the vest. Raji is a guess, based on their desire to go to a 3-4; where they can put him at nose.
10. 49ers- Mark Sanchez, QB (backup plan- Michael Oher, OL)- I'm either thinking they're playing it coy by deflecting off Sanchez, or they're obviously not and will take Oher. This is a hard read right now, but is also a strong trading spot for the Jets.
11. Bills- Everette Brown, DL (backup plan- Orapko and Oher)- I'm sure the Bills will be looking to upgrade their pass rush, unless they trade their LT; then they would select Oher. If they can sign him, they'll take the best pass rusher.
12. Broncos- Brian Orapko, DL (backup plan- Robert Ayers and Jarron Gilbert, DL)- With everyone convinced the Broncos will want a young QB, I'm not sure that will happen until later in the draft. They have ammo to move up, but I think they will want to draft heavily on the defensive side.
13. Redskins- Michael Oher, OL (backup plan- Ayers and Gilbert)- I'm pretty convinced they'll select Oher if they don't trade back, which they don't usually do.
14. Saints- Chris Wells, RB (backup plan-)- I'm almost 100% sure this will happen. Lock this one up, unless there's a trade involving the Chargers.
15. Texans- Brian Cushing, LB (backup plan- Moreno, RB)- This pick makes sense, although I like Zac Diles. Cushing would play strong, and Diles would backup at both SLB and MLB.
16. Chargers- Knowshon Moreno, RB (backup plan- Tyson Jackson, DL)- This is a talented team without any obvious needs, and they'll have to replace LT2 soon. Sproles isn't an everydown backer in their eyes, and their GM has let that be known.
17. Jets- Josh Freeman, QB (backup plan-)- This is such a natural fit, so I'll call this a lock now.
18. Broncos- Jarron Gilbert, DL (backup plan- Brandon Pettigrew, TE)- Gilbert's star is rising fast, and he's almost a lock to go in the first round. I wouldn't be shocked if the Lions didn't love him at #20. He's very versatile, and has a body he can grow into. Very projectable.
19. Bucs- Robert Ayers, DL (backup plan- Maybin)- This is not a spot where I see Harvin going. Ayers could go much earlier. He's a good player on a bad college team, and those players usually fall.
20. Lions- Rey Maualuga, LB (backup plan- Malcolm Jenkins, Peria Jerry)- The Lions have let it be known how badly they need a MLB by not carrying one on their current roster, so they'll need to draft more than one. If Gilbert is available, I believe the Lions could also pop him, plus there's a strong chance they'll trade down here. I believe they wouldn't be crazy about the players available here.
21. Eagles- Shawn Nelson, TE (backup plan- Jenkins)- The Eagles have a need at TE, and Nelson is an underrated player. Some players are falling.
22. Vikings- Alex Mack, C (backup plan-)- The Vikings need a center obviously, and they do draft linemen high often.
23. Patriots- Aaron Maybin, DL (backup plan- Jenkins)- Still, not a single CB has been taken. There will be a ton taken in the 2nd round, though.
24. Falcons- Brandon Pettigrew, TE (backup plan- Jenkins)- I believe this could be a lock, if Pettigrew is there.
25. Dolphins- Pat White, QB (backup plan- Clay Mathews)- I believe they are crazy enough to pull this off.
26. Ravens- Malcolm Jenkins, CB/S (backup plan- Mathews)- The dam breaks! Finally, a corner! (if he ends up at corner, of course).
27. Colts- Peria Jerry, DT (backup plan- Vontae Davis)- As long as they have a need at DT (which seems like a long time), they'll have to continue to take them. This is a good fit.
28. Eagles- Clay Mathews, LB (backup plan- Barwin)- Mathews has some versatility, and could give the Eagles alot of options. Kind of surprised he's still there.
29. Giants- Kenny Britt, WR (backup plan- Robiskie)- The Giants have been connected with Britt, although they are famous for sticking to their board regardless of position.
30. Titans- Ziggy Hood, DT (backup plan- Barwin)- The Titans have to replace Haynesworth, and Hood's a good player.
31. Cards- Donald Brown, RB (backup plan-)- The Cards have a strong need for a full-time RB. Brown is solid.
32. Steelers- William Beatty, OL (backup plan-)- For a great team, they have an ordinary line. I'd be shocked if they didn't go linemen here.
33. Lions- Sean Smith, CB (backup plan- Connor Barwin, DL)- Smith is versatile, and could be slotted in at corner or safety. He can run with bigger WR's, and will get alot of practice against Johnson.
1. Lions- Matt Stafford, QB (backup plan- Jason Smith, OL)- I'm 90% convinced that Stafford will be signed and selected for the pick. The Lions aren't saying much, but the fact they haven't signed a backup QB speaks volumes right now.
2. Rams- Jason Smith, OL (backup plan- Eugene Monroe, OL)- I'm 100% convinced they will select a tackle, they don't have a good backup plan if they don't. They've made their plans obvious by releasing Pace, and not signing a LT.
3. Chiefs- Eugene Monroe, OL (backup plan- Aaron Curry, LB)- I'm not 100% sure about this, but the recent signing of Zach Thomas is a head scratcher. They could move Albert to LG, and reunite the Virginia left side. Scott Pioli does have connections with Virginia HC Al Groh, and would feel safe with this selection.
4. Seahawks- Aaron Curry, LB (backup plan- Mark Sanchez, QB)- If he's there, I believe the Seahawks are lying in wait to take Curry. Otherwise, this is a QB landing spot.
5. Browns- Michael Crabtree, WR (backup plan- Brian Orapko, DE)- I think the Browns absolutely feel a need to select Crabtree. I also think they could still trade Edwards for picks. They have a pass rushing need also.
6. Bengals- Andre Smith, OL (backup plan- Jeremy Maclin, WR)- The thing about the Bengals is they usually draft linemen high, and they don't scout well.
7. Raiders- Darrius Heyward-Bey, WR (backup plan- Jeremy Maclin, WR)- The Raiders won't select a player like Crabtree they don't have a time for, but they will select a player like DHB that they have top times on. I'm almost ready to call this a lock.
8. Jaguars- Jeremy Maclin, WR (backup plan- Michael Oher, OL)- The Jaguars have had issues with the WR position for a long time now, and this has become the achilles heel of their team. I don't see many room for trades yet, but anything can happen.
9. Packers- BJ Raji, DT (backup plan- Brian Orakpo, DE)- One thing about the current Packers administration is that they will draft a ton of defensive linemen year in and year out. Other wise, they don't show their cards, and play it close to the vest. Raji is a guess, based on their desire to go to a 3-4; where they can put him at nose.
10. 49ers- Mark Sanchez, QB (backup plan- Michael Oher, OL)- I'm either thinking they're playing it coy by deflecting off Sanchez, or they're obviously not and will take Oher. This is a hard read right now, but is also a strong trading spot for the Jets.
11. Bills- Everette Brown, DL (backup plan- Orapko and Oher)- I'm sure the Bills will be looking to upgrade their pass rush, unless they trade their LT; then they would select Oher. If they can sign him, they'll take the best pass rusher.
12. Broncos- Brian Orapko, DL (backup plan- Robert Ayers and Jarron Gilbert, DL)- With everyone convinced the Broncos will want a young QB, I'm not sure that will happen until later in the draft. They have ammo to move up, but I think they will want to draft heavily on the defensive side.
13. Redskins- Michael Oher, OL (backup plan- Ayers and Gilbert)- I'm pretty convinced they'll select Oher if they don't trade back, which they don't usually do.
14. Saints- Chris Wells, RB (backup plan-)- I'm almost 100% sure this will happen. Lock this one up, unless there's a trade involving the Chargers.
15. Texans- Brian Cushing, LB (backup plan- Moreno, RB)- This pick makes sense, although I like Zac Diles. Cushing would play strong, and Diles would backup at both SLB and MLB.
16. Chargers- Knowshon Moreno, RB (backup plan- Tyson Jackson, DL)- This is a talented team without any obvious needs, and they'll have to replace LT2 soon. Sproles isn't an everydown backer in their eyes, and their GM has let that be known.
17. Jets- Josh Freeman, QB (backup plan-)- This is such a natural fit, so I'll call this a lock now.
18. Broncos- Jarron Gilbert, DL (backup plan- Brandon Pettigrew, TE)- Gilbert's star is rising fast, and he's almost a lock to go in the first round. I wouldn't be shocked if the Lions didn't love him at #20. He's very versatile, and has a body he can grow into. Very projectable.
19. Bucs- Robert Ayers, DL (backup plan- Maybin)- This is not a spot where I see Harvin going. Ayers could go much earlier. He's a good player on a bad college team, and those players usually fall.
20. Lions- Rey Maualuga, LB (backup plan- Malcolm Jenkins, Peria Jerry)- The Lions have let it be known how badly they need a MLB by not carrying one on their current roster, so they'll need to draft more than one. If Gilbert is available, I believe the Lions could also pop him, plus there's a strong chance they'll trade down here. I believe they wouldn't be crazy about the players available here.
21. Eagles- Shawn Nelson, TE (backup plan- Jenkins)- The Eagles have a need at TE, and Nelson is an underrated player. Some players are falling.
22. Vikings- Alex Mack, C (backup plan-)- The Vikings need a center obviously, and they do draft linemen high often.
23. Patriots- Aaron Maybin, DL (backup plan- Jenkins)- Still, not a single CB has been taken. There will be a ton taken in the 2nd round, though.
24. Falcons- Brandon Pettigrew, TE (backup plan- Jenkins)- I believe this could be a lock, if Pettigrew is there.
25. Dolphins- Pat White, QB (backup plan- Clay Mathews)- I believe they are crazy enough to pull this off.
26. Ravens- Malcolm Jenkins, CB/S (backup plan- Mathews)- The dam breaks! Finally, a corner! (if he ends up at corner, of course).
27. Colts- Peria Jerry, DT (backup plan- Vontae Davis)- As long as they have a need at DT (which seems like a long time), they'll have to continue to take them. This is a good fit.
28. Eagles- Clay Mathews, LB (backup plan- Barwin)- Mathews has some versatility, and could give the Eagles alot of options. Kind of surprised he's still there.
29. Giants- Kenny Britt, WR (backup plan- Robiskie)- The Giants have been connected with Britt, although they are famous for sticking to their board regardless of position.
30. Titans- Ziggy Hood, DT (backup plan- Barwin)- The Titans have to replace Haynesworth, and Hood's a good player.
31. Cards- Donald Brown, RB (backup plan-)- The Cards have a strong need for a full-time RB. Brown is solid.
32. Steelers- William Beatty, OL (backup plan-)- For a great team, they have an ordinary line. I'd be shocked if they didn't go linemen here.
33. Lions- Sean Smith, CB (backup plan- Connor Barwin, DL)- Smith is versatile, and could be slotted in at corner or safety. He can run with bigger WR's, and will get alot of practice against Johnson.
Friday, March 6, 2009
My futile attempt at a seven round mock draft...
Lion's picks:
1. Matt Stafford, QB
1b. Rey Maualuga, LB
2. William Beatty, LT
3. Cornelius Ingram, TE
3b. Dorell Scott, DT
5. Mike Wallace, WR
6. Stanley Arnoux, LB
6b. Lydon Murtha, OL
I expect the Lions to receive 3 comp picks; one in the fourth, sixth, and seventh rounds.
1. Matt Stafford, QB
1b. Rey Maualuga, LB
2. William Beatty, LT
3. Cornelius Ingram, TE
3b. Dorell Scott, DT
5. Mike Wallace, WR
6. Stanley Arnoux, LB
6b. Lydon Murtha, OL
I expect the Lions to receive 3 comp picks; one in the fourth, sixth, and seventh rounds.
Wednesday, February 25, 2009
My list of the top 100 prospects in the 2009 draft...
1. Matt Stafford, QB; UGA: Much has been debated as to his ability to become a top QB, but he is to me the most talented player in the draft. He just turned 21 years old, and is one of the most talented QB's I've ever seen. He has a big arm, and plays with a moxie of a more experienced player. He has big game experience, and is 3-0 in bowl games at Georgia.
2. Aaron Curry, LB; Wake Forrest: Easily the best defensive player in this year's draft, Curry can be found in every play during a Wake game. He's never far away from the action. He destroyed the combine, showing elite level athleticism to show that he'll be a force to be reckoned with at the next level. For some teams, he'll prove more valuable at the will, but I believe he'll move inside to the mike, where he'll cause havoc.
3. B.J. Raji, DT; BC: Although not quite up to the talent level of the top two DT's from 2008's draft (Glenn Dorsey and Sedrick Ellis); Raji is no walk in the park for the opposition. He has an excellent motor, and plays with a chip on his shoulder. He does split gaps, so there are times when he misses, but he does hit home runs from time to time.
4. Jason Smith, LT, Baylor: It's hard to believe that he's only played left tackle for three years, so he does show an upside. At this moment, I believe Eugene Monroe to be the better player by the slimmest of margins; although projecting down a few years I feel that Smith will have the better career.
5. Eugene Monroe, LT, Virginia: He is pretty technically sound, and takes good care of his QB. He'll be known as a reliable LT, just not an elite one. I feel he's pretty close to his ceiling, and should be able to start from day one.
6. Michael Crabtree, WR, Texas Tech: The fact that he isn't able to provide a 40 time doesn't bug me as much as the fact that his height is only 6'1", when it was thought that he was two inches taller. There are some signs of buyer beware with him, such as the foot injury. He's a really good player, I just don't think that he's a great player.
7. Everette Brown, DE, FSU: I've used Andre Carter comps on Brown before, and I believe that is who he is. The difference between him and Orakpo is that he's got more moves, and plays more physically at the point of attack. They're both superior ends/olb's. Transitional types.
8. Brian Orakpo, DE, Texas: Orakpo comes at you from the same direction, but you have to be on your horse to catch up with him. He does ride out of the picture often, so he has to improve on playing the run.
9. Jeremy Maclin, WR, Missouri: Maclin might have more natural talent than the more heralded Michael Crabtree, but he also needs to show more consistancy catching the ball. He has good ability in the open field, and has return capabilities.
10. Knowshon Moreno, RB, Georgia: I see Moreno as a cross between Reggie Bush and Kevin Jones, if that is possible. He's not a franchise back per se, but he's a solid #1 type who can carry the mail and catch out of the backfield.
11. Brian Cushing, LB, USC: Cushing is exactly the same type of player that Chad Greenway is, and could be a Pro-Bowler type soon. He can help alot of teams in a lot of ways.
12. Brandon Pettigrew, TE, Oklahoma State: He's a throwback to the type of TE that used to be more prevelant back in the day. He's the type that you can use against the top pass rushers to help in pass protection, he has great hands, and can help in the passing game with big catches; and he also blocks well in the running game. He's a rare bird, a three down TE.
13. Mark Sanchez, QB, USC: My instincts tell me that this is too high for him, but he can be a solid system QB if he goes to the right team. There is a huge gap between him and Stafford. Sanchez needs to go to a west coast type offense.
14. Andre Smith, T, Alabama: This is as far as he should fall, although he'd be a tough cat to pull the trigger on. If anybody shouldn't be invited to New York for the draft, it's Smith.
15. Aaron Maybin, DE/OLB, Penn State: He jumps out with his super first step. He reminds me of Terrell Suggs. Very similar 40 times, and very similar players.
16. Vontae Davis, CB, Illinois: He's got to show that he's not going to bust like his brothers, but it would concern me. He's a good player, who should be better based on his athletic ability.
17. Chris Wells, RB, OSU: He's a safe player to take, as long as he is healthy. He got nicked up a bit, but nothing too major. He reminds me of Jamal Lewis.
18. Peria Jerry, DT, Mississippi: He has alot of energy for a 300 lber, and is a pretty good slasher type.
19. Michael Oher, T, Mississippi: He's extremely similar to Gosder Cherilus. Even makes the same mistakes, although he's a better left tackle than Gos.
20. Tyson Jackson, DE, LSU: A ready made player that will have a predictable career playing two downs, and getting a couple of sacks, but plays the run extremely well on the left side.
21. Rey Maualuga, LB, USC: He isn't quite the player I thought he'd be, but he is solid if he healthy's up. He hit a snag at the combine when he reinjured a sore hammy. He'll be a consistant MLB who isn't going to help in passing downs.
22. Malcolm Jenkins, CB, OSU: He's a cover two corner who might move to FS in the NFL. He has good size and can hit, but he can get exposed.
23. Alphonso Smith, CB, Wake Forest: He's Dre Bly reincarnated. Exactly the same type of ball snatching ball hog who's good for about 7-8 int's per year. Great ball skills, but a better tackler than Bly.
24. Larry English, DE/OLB, N.Illinois: He's got a nice motor with nice pass rush skills. He'd be higher if he projected to play better against the run.
25. Leshean McCoy, RB, Pitt: Really the most legit HR threat in this draft, he also might turn out to be J.J. Arrington.
The rest...
26. Alex Mack, C, Cal 27. Hakeem Nicks, WR, UNC 28. Clint Sintim, OLB, UVa 29. Robert Ayers, DE, Tennessee 30. Sean Smith, CB, Utah 31. Darrius Heyward-Bey, WR, Maryland 32. Clay Matthews, LB, USC 33. Louis Delmas, S, WMU 34. William Beatty, LT, UConn 35. Percy Harvin, WR, Florida 36. Max Unger, C, Oregon 37. Eric Wood, C, Louisville 38. Donald Brown, RB, UConn 39. Brian Robiskie, WR, OSU 40. Shawn Nelson, TE, So.Miss 41. Nate Davis, QB, Ball State 42. Connor Barwin, DE/TE/LB, Cinci 43. James Laurinaitis, LB, OSU 44. D.J. Moore, CB, Vandy 45. Evander Hood, DT, Missouri 46. Eben Britton, RT, Arizona 47. Jarron Gilbert, DE, San Jose St. 48. Brandon Lewis, CB, Oregon State 49. Darrius Butler, CB, UConn 50. Ron Brace, DT, BC 51. Zack Follett, LB, Cal 52. Michael Johnson, DE, GTU 53. Rashad Johnson, S, Alabama 54. Asher Allen, CB, Georgia 55. Kenny Britt, WR, Rutgers 56. Kenan Lewis, CB, Oregon State 57. Pat White, QB, WVU 58. Jasper Brinkley, LB, South Carolina 59. Andre Brown, RB, NCState 60. Darry Beckwith, LB, LSU 61. James Casey, TE, Rice 62. Marcus Freeman, OLB, OSU 63. Juaquin Iglesias, WR, Oklahoma 64. Mohammed Massaquoi, WR, Georgia 65. Duke Robinson, OL, Oklahoma 66. Jared Cook, TE, South Carolina 67. Josh Freeman, QB, Kansas State 68. Scott McKillop, LB, Pitt 69. Rashad Jennings, RB, Liberty 70. Deon Butler, WR, Penn State 71. Jon Luigs, C, Arkansas 72. Louis Murphy, WR, Florida 73. Mike Thomas, WR, Arizona 74. Antoine Caldwell, OL, Alabama 75. Patrick Chung, S, Oregon 76. Cody Brown, DE/LB, UConn 77. Maurice Evans, DE, Penn State 78. Fili Moala, DT, USC 79. Victor Harris, CB, VT 80. William Moore, S, Missouri 81. David Bruton, S, Notre Dame 82. Kory Sheets, RB, Purdue 83. Glen Coffee, RB, Alabama 84. Cornelius Ingram, TE, Florida 85. Travis Beckum, TE, Wisconsin 86. Tyronne Green, OL, Auburn 87. Jamon Meredith, OL, South Carolina 88. Mike Mickens, CB, Cinci 89. Sen'Derrick Marks, DT, Auburn 90. Javon Ringer, RB, MSU 91. Paul Kruger, DE, Utah 92. Lawrence Sidbury, DE, Richmond 93. Kyle Moore, DL, USC 94. Dannell Ellerbe, LB, Georgia 95. Tyrone McKenzie, LB, South Florida 96. CQ Shipley, C, Penn State 97. John Phillips, TE, Virginia 98. Phil Loadholt, OL, Oklahoma 99. Terence Taylor, DT, UM 100. Darcel McBath, S, Texas Tech
2. Aaron Curry, LB; Wake Forrest: Easily the best defensive player in this year's draft, Curry can be found in every play during a Wake game. He's never far away from the action. He destroyed the combine, showing elite level athleticism to show that he'll be a force to be reckoned with at the next level. For some teams, he'll prove more valuable at the will, but I believe he'll move inside to the mike, where he'll cause havoc.
3. B.J. Raji, DT; BC: Although not quite up to the talent level of the top two DT's from 2008's draft (Glenn Dorsey and Sedrick Ellis); Raji is no walk in the park for the opposition. He has an excellent motor, and plays with a chip on his shoulder. He does split gaps, so there are times when he misses, but he does hit home runs from time to time.
4. Jason Smith, LT, Baylor: It's hard to believe that he's only played left tackle for three years, so he does show an upside. At this moment, I believe Eugene Monroe to be the better player by the slimmest of margins; although projecting down a few years I feel that Smith will have the better career.
5. Eugene Monroe, LT, Virginia: He is pretty technically sound, and takes good care of his QB. He'll be known as a reliable LT, just not an elite one. I feel he's pretty close to his ceiling, and should be able to start from day one.
6. Michael Crabtree, WR, Texas Tech: The fact that he isn't able to provide a 40 time doesn't bug me as much as the fact that his height is only 6'1", when it was thought that he was two inches taller. There are some signs of buyer beware with him, such as the foot injury. He's a really good player, I just don't think that he's a great player.
7. Everette Brown, DE, FSU: I've used Andre Carter comps on Brown before, and I believe that is who he is. The difference between him and Orakpo is that he's got more moves, and plays more physically at the point of attack. They're both superior ends/olb's. Transitional types.
8. Brian Orakpo, DE, Texas: Orakpo comes at you from the same direction, but you have to be on your horse to catch up with him. He does ride out of the picture often, so he has to improve on playing the run.
9. Jeremy Maclin, WR, Missouri: Maclin might have more natural talent than the more heralded Michael Crabtree, but he also needs to show more consistancy catching the ball. He has good ability in the open field, and has return capabilities.
10. Knowshon Moreno, RB, Georgia: I see Moreno as a cross between Reggie Bush and Kevin Jones, if that is possible. He's not a franchise back per se, but he's a solid #1 type who can carry the mail and catch out of the backfield.
11. Brian Cushing, LB, USC: Cushing is exactly the same type of player that Chad Greenway is, and could be a Pro-Bowler type soon. He can help alot of teams in a lot of ways.
12. Brandon Pettigrew, TE, Oklahoma State: He's a throwback to the type of TE that used to be more prevelant back in the day. He's the type that you can use against the top pass rushers to help in pass protection, he has great hands, and can help in the passing game with big catches; and he also blocks well in the running game. He's a rare bird, a three down TE.
13. Mark Sanchez, QB, USC: My instincts tell me that this is too high for him, but he can be a solid system QB if he goes to the right team. There is a huge gap between him and Stafford. Sanchez needs to go to a west coast type offense.
14. Andre Smith, T, Alabama: This is as far as he should fall, although he'd be a tough cat to pull the trigger on. If anybody shouldn't be invited to New York for the draft, it's Smith.
15. Aaron Maybin, DE/OLB, Penn State: He jumps out with his super first step. He reminds me of Terrell Suggs. Very similar 40 times, and very similar players.
16. Vontae Davis, CB, Illinois: He's got to show that he's not going to bust like his brothers, but it would concern me. He's a good player, who should be better based on his athletic ability.
17. Chris Wells, RB, OSU: He's a safe player to take, as long as he is healthy. He got nicked up a bit, but nothing too major. He reminds me of Jamal Lewis.
18. Peria Jerry, DT, Mississippi: He has alot of energy for a 300 lber, and is a pretty good slasher type.
19. Michael Oher, T, Mississippi: He's extremely similar to Gosder Cherilus. Even makes the same mistakes, although he's a better left tackle than Gos.
20. Tyson Jackson, DE, LSU: A ready made player that will have a predictable career playing two downs, and getting a couple of sacks, but plays the run extremely well on the left side.
21. Rey Maualuga, LB, USC: He isn't quite the player I thought he'd be, but he is solid if he healthy's up. He hit a snag at the combine when he reinjured a sore hammy. He'll be a consistant MLB who isn't going to help in passing downs.
22. Malcolm Jenkins, CB, OSU: He's a cover two corner who might move to FS in the NFL. He has good size and can hit, but he can get exposed.
23. Alphonso Smith, CB, Wake Forest: He's Dre Bly reincarnated. Exactly the same type of ball snatching ball hog who's good for about 7-8 int's per year. Great ball skills, but a better tackler than Bly.
24. Larry English, DE/OLB, N.Illinois: He's got a nice motor with nice pass rush skills. He'd be higher if he projected to play better against the run.
25. Leshean McCoy, RB, Pitt: Really the most legit HR threat in this draft, he also might turn out to be J.J. Arrington.
The rest...
26. Alex Mack, C, Cal 27. Hakeem Nicks, WR, UNC 28. Clint Sintim, OLB, UVa 29. Robert Ayers, DE, Tennessee 30. Sean Smith, CB, Utah 31. Darrius Heyward-Bey, WR, Maryland 32. Clay Matthews, LB, USC 33. Louis Delmas, S, WMU 34. William Beatty, LT, UConn 35. Percy Harvin, WR, Florida 36. Max Unger, C, Oregon 37. Eric Wood, C, Louisville 38. Donald Brown, RB, UConn 39. Brian Robiskie, WR, OSU 40. Shawn Nelson, TE, So.Miss 41. Nate Davis, QB, Ball State 42. Connor Barwin, DE/TE/LB, Cinci 43. James Laurinaitis, LB, OSU 44. D.J. Moore, CB, Vandy 45. Evander Hood, DT, Missouri 46. Eben Britton, RT, Arizona 47. Jarron Gilbert, DE, San Jose St. 48. Brandon Lewis, CB, Oregon State 49. Darrius Butler, CB, UConn 50. Ron Brace, DT, BC 51. Zack Follett, LB, Cal 52. Michael Johnson, DE, GTU 53. Rashad Johnson, S, Alabama 54. Asher Allen, CB, Georgia 55. Kenny Britt, WR, Rutgers 56. Kenan Lewis, CB, Oregon State 57. Pat White, QB, WVU 58. Jasper Brinkley, LB, South Carolina 59. Andre Brown, RB, NCState 60. Darry Beckwith, LB, LSU 61. James Casey, TE, Rice 62. Marcus Freeman, OLB, OSU 63. Juaquin Iglesias, WR, Oklahoma 64. Mohammed Massaquoi, WR, Georgia 65. Duke Robinson, OL, Oklahoma 66. Jared Cook, TE, South Carolina 67. Josh Freeman, QB, Kansas State 68. Scott McKillop, LB, Pitt 69. Rashad Jennings, RB, Liberty 70. Deon Butler, WR, Penn State 71. Jon Luigs, C, Arkansas 72. Louis Murphy, WR, Florida 73. Mike Thomas, WR, Arizona 74. Antoine Caldwell, OL, Alabama 75. Patrick Chung, S, Oregon 76. Cody Brown, DE/LB, UConn 77. Maurice Evans, DE, Penn State 78. Fili Moala, DT, USC 79. Victor Harris, CB, VT 80. William Moore, S, Missouri 81. David Bruton, S, Notre Dame 82. Kory Sheets, RB, Purdue 83. Glen Coffee, RB, Alabama 84. Cornelius Ingram, TE, Florida 85. Travis Beckum, TE, Wisconsin 86. Tyronne Green, OL, Auburn 87. Jamon Meredith, OL, South Carolina 88. Mike Mickens, CB, Cinci 89. Sen'Derrick Marks, DT, Auburn 90. Javon Ringer, RB, MSU 91. Paul Kruger, DE, Utah 92. Lawrence Sidbury, DE, Richmond 93. Kyle Moore, DL, USC 94. Dannell Ellerbe, LB, Georgia 95. Tyrone McKenzie, LB, South Florida 96. CQ Shipley, C, Penn State 97. John Phillips, TE, Virginia 98. Phil Loadholt, OL, Oklahoma 99. Terence Taylor, DT, UM 100. Darcel McBath, S, Texas Tech
Monday, February 16, 2009
Senior Bowl Positional Detail: Safety
North Squad:
1. William Moore, 6-00.1, 223 lbs.- He really struggled all week long, and his ranking is falling fast. Doesn't have the size necessary to move to LB, although that could happen. Gets lost in coverage.
2. Patrick Chung, 5-11.1, 207 lbs.- He had an outstanding week, and showed great awareness and ball skills. He might not be the best athlete, but his preparedness is top notch. He's always where he needs to be.
3. Louis Delmas, 5-11.2, 197 lbs.- He's slowly moving up to the top of the safety class, although I remain skeptical. He is very good in coverage, although his ball skills need to improve. He needs to continue his good Sr.Bowl week with an outstanding combine to clinch the top spot, although this isn't the best class of safeties.
4. David Bruton, 6-01.6, 210 lbs.- Very good size, will have to see what his speed is. Always seems to be a day late and a dollar short, but I think he needs to move closer to the line, and be an "in the box" type.
South Squad:
1. Derek Pegues, 5-09.3, 193 lbs.- For his size, he likes to get his nose dirty. He has decent coverage skills, and can tackle.
2. Chip Vaughn, 6-01.0, 218 lbs.- He struggled in space with coverage, and didn't tackle well. He needs a good combine.
3. Michael Hamlin, 6-02.0, 207 lbs.- He's got a nice nose for the football, and makes plays. He's either a mid 2nd to an early third rounder.
4. Rashad Johnson, 5-11.4, 195 lbs.- Very experienced, very steady player with some ball skills. He makes plays. Solid second rounder.
1. William Moore, 6-00.1, 223 lbs.- He really struggled all week long, and his ranking is falling fast. Doesn't have the size necessary to move to LB, although that could happen. Gets lost in coverage.
2. Patrick Chung, 5-11.1, 207 lbs.- He had an outstanding week, and showed great awareness and ball skills. He might not be the best athlete, but his preparedness is top notch. He's always where he needs to be.
3. Louis Delmas, 5-11.2, 197 lbs.- He's slowly moving up to the top of the safety class, although I remain skeptical. He is very good in coverage, although his ball skills need to improve. He needs to continue his good Sr.Bowl week with an outstanding combine to clinch the top spot, although this isn't the best class of safeties.
4. David Bruton, 6-01.6, 210 lbs.- Very good size, will have to see what his speed is. Always seems to be a day late and a dollar short, but I think he needs to move closer to the line, and be an "in the box" type.
South Squad:
1. Derek Pegues, 5-09.3, 193 lbs.- For his size, he likes to get his nose dirty. He has decent coverage skills, and can tackle.
2. Chip Vaughn, 6-01.0, 218 lbs.- He struggled in space with coverage, and didn't tackle well. He needs a good combine.
3. Michael Hamlin, 6-02.0, 207 lbs.- He's got a nice nose for the football, and makes plays. He's either a mid 2nd to an early third rounder.
4. Rashad Johnson, 5-11.4, 195 lbs.- Very experienced, very steady player with some ball skills. He makes plays. Solid second rounder.
Senior Bowl Positional Detail: Corners
North Squad:
1. Darius Butler, 5-10.1, 178 lbs.- Moves great, but doesn't have great ball skills. This will be his downfall, since he does everything else well.
2. Victor "Macho" Harris, 5-10.7, 186 lbs.- Plays much bigger than his size would indicate. Plays fearlessly, with a chip on his shoulder. He's the type that needs to be drafted based on his attitude. He rubs off well on other players. He's another rat. He knows what he needs to do to get better. One of my favorite players.
3. Deangelo Smith, 5-10.4, 191 lbs.- Leaves you wanting more on the playing field. Doesn't play the ball well, doesn't play his man extremely well. Didn't tackle extremely well. He was disappointing during the Sr.Bowl.
4. Keenan Lewis, 6-00.5, 198 lbs.- Plays very nice press coverage. Very physically imposing. Can match up well with most receivers. Needs to improve ball skills.
5. Mike Mickens, 5-11.0, 176 lbs.- He has a nice pair of hands, but needs to play better in space. Better in press coverage than off-man.
South Squad:
1. Coye Francies, 6-00.2, 179 lbs.- Really underrated, and came into his own when he showed up in Mobile. Is definitely a cover two type, but shows athleticism and nice ball skills.
2. Alphonso Smith, 5-08.7, 193 lbs.- Might have been the best player at the Senior Bowl all week, along with B.J. Raji. Was extremely dominant in coverage. Outstanding ball skills that will define him. Great tackler, there isn't much more to ask for from the corner position.
3. Ellis Lankster, 5-09.1, 191 lbs.- Struggled in coverage a bit, but doesn't lack in the effort category. Moves very well, and plays alot of press. Needs to play better in space.
4. Domonique Johnson, 6-01.4, 192 lbs.- Great size/speed combo. Very raw skills-wise. Might be a late bloomer type. Must keep an eye on him.
5. Sherrod Martin, 6-00.6, 197 lbs.- Also has great size and speed. Flashed during coverage drills. Showed some hutzpah.
1. Darius Butler, 5-10.1, 178 lbs.- Moves great, but doesn't have great ball skills. This will be his downfall, since he does everything else well.
2. Victor "Macho" Harris, 5-10.7, 186 lbs.- Plays much bigger than his size would indicate. Plays fearlessly, with a chip on his shoulder. He's the type that needs to be drafted based on his attitude. He rubs off well on other players. He's another rat. He knows what he needs to do to get better. One of my favorite players.
3. Deangelo Smith, 5-10.4, 191 lbs.- Leaves you wanting more on the playing field. Doesn't play the ball well, doesn't play his man extremely well. Didn't tackle extremely well. He was disappointing during the Sr.Bowl.
4. Keenan Lewis, 6-00.5, 198 lbs.- Plays very nice press coverage. Very physically imposing. Can match up well with most receivers. Needs to improve ball skills.
5. Mike Mickens, 5-11.0, 176 lbs.- He has a nice pair of hands, but needs to play better in space. Better in press coverage than off-man.
South Squad:
1. Coye Francies, 6-00.2, 179 lbs.- Really underrated, and came into his own when he showed up in Mobile. Is definitely a cover two type, but shows athleticism and nice ball skills.
2. Alphonso Smith, 5-08.7, 193 lbs.- Might have been the best player at the Senior Bowl all week, along with B.J. Raji. Was extremely dominant in coverage. Outstanding ball skills that will define him. Great tackler, there isn't much more to ask for from the corner position.
3. Ellis Lankster, 5-09.1, 191 lbs.- Struggled in coverage a bit, but doesn't lack in the effort category. Moves very well, and plays alot of press. Needs to play better in space.
4. Domonique Johnson, 6-01.4, 192 lbs.- Great size/speed combo. Very raw skills-wise. Might be a late bloomer type. Must keep an eye on him.
5. Sherrod Martin, 6-00.6, 197 lbs.- Also has great size and speed. Flashed during coverage drills. Showed some hutzpah.
Senior Bowl Positional Detail: Linebackers
North Squad:
1. Nik Harris, 6-02.0, 233 lbs.- It looked like he took well to the position switch, which is good for him to show he can accept coaching easily. He didn't look out of place, and I'd be surprised if he wasn't drafted high 2nd as a LB.
2. Scott McKillop, 6-01.0, 243 lbs.- He takes really nice angles, and moves well through the junk. He's underrated in my book. He also has nice size, and will be a great value if drafted too late. I see him as a mid rounder with upside.
3. Clint Sintim, 6-02.5, 249 lbs.- He's been getting too much pub for me, he always leaves me wanting to see more. If he goes in the first, he's being over valued. He's either a 4-3 sam, or a 3-4 middle.
4. Tyrone McKenzie, 6-01.7, 244 lbs.- He hasn't shown alot of explosion, but gets to some plays by anticipating well. He's not afraid to get his nose dirty, and is pretty versatile. Not a great athlete, but more of a grunt.
5. Marcus Freeman, 6-00.5, 235 lbs.- He seemingly gets in on every play. He's got a good nose for the ball, and does every thing well. He might not be as big as you'd like him to be, however.
6. Zack Follett, 6-01.6, 236 lbs.- When you talk about under the radar types, here's your man. Great hitter, and a great nose for the ball. Very instinctive, and a better than average athlete. I like him alot.
South Squad:
1. Brian Cushing, 6-03.1, 245 lbs.- Does everything extremely well. Projects to be an all-pro level LB who can be versatile to play many positions. Showed some pass rush ability.
2. Ashley Palmer, 6-01.4, 223 lbs.- Might be too small to play every down. Has some good quicks, and is good in coverage. Might be a third down type nickle backer.
3. Clay Matthews, 6-03.0, 246 lbs.- Showed more redeeming qualities than expected. Showed a great bull rush technique when rushing QB. Can cover, and play the run. Is moving up the ranks right now.
4. Darry Beckwith, 6-00.3, 233 lbs.- Is a nice little player who needs more size. He moves well, but could he put on the weight? Does better in coverage against the run. He's very experienced.
5. Rey Maualuga, 6-01.7, 254 lbs.- Is he a three down backer? No. Does he give you high quality reps when on the field? Yes. Is he good enough to justify such a high rating? That's the question that must be answered. I do personnally prefer James Laurinaitis, who plays with more balance. Maualuga is a solid first round player.
6. Moise Fokou, 6-01.1, 228 lbs.- He showed some athletic ability, but projects to a mid-lower round pick. He played well in the game.
1. Nik Harris, 6-02.0, 233 lbs.- It looked like he took well to the position switch, which is good for him to show he can accept coaching easily. He didn't look out of place, and I'd be surprised if he wasn't drafted high 2nd as a LB.
2. Scott McKillop, 6-01.0, 243 lbs.- He takes really nice angles, and moves well through the junk. He's underrated in my book. He also has nice size, and will be a great value if drafted too late. I see him as a mid rounder with upside.
3. Clint Sintim, 6-02.5, 249 lbs.- He's been getting too much pub for me, he always leaves me wanting to see more. If he goes in the first, he's being over valued. He's either a 4-3 sam, or a 3-4 middle.
4. Tyrone McKenzie, 6-01.7, 244 lbs.- He hasn't shown alot of explosion, but gets to some plays by anticipating well. He's not afraid to get his nose dirty, and is pretty versatile. Not a great athlete, but more of a grunt.
5. Marcus Freeman, 6-00.5, 235 lbs.- He seemingly gets in on every play. He's got a good nose for the ball, and does every thing well. He might not be as big as you'd like him to be, however.
6. Zack Follett, 6-01.6, 236 lbs.- When you talk about under the radar types, here's your man. Great hitter, and a great nose for the ball. Very instinctive, and a better than average athlete. I like him alot.
South Squad:
1. Brian Cushing, 6-03.1, 245 lbs.- Does everything extremely well. Projects to be an all-pro level LB who can be versatile to play many positions. Showed some pass rush ability.
2. Ashley Palmer, 6-01.4, 223 lbs.- Might be too small to play every down. Has some good quicks, and is good in coverage. Might be a third down type nickle backer.
3. Clay Matthews, 6-03.0, 246 lbs.- Showed more redeeming qualities than expected. Showed a great bull rush technique when rushing QB. Can cover, and play the run. Is moving up the ranks right now.
4. Darry Beckwith, 6-00.3, 233 lbs.- Is a nice little player who needs more size. He moves well, but could he put on the weight? Does better in coverage against the run. He's very experienced.
5. Rey Maualuga, 6-01.7, 254 lbs.- Is he a three down backer? No. Does he give you high quality reps when on the field? Yes. Is he good enough to justify such a high rating? That's the question that must be answered. I do personnally prefer James Laurinaitis, who plays with more balance. Maualuga is a solid first round player.
6. Moise Fokou, 6-01.1, 228 lbs.- He showed some athletic ability, but projects to a mid-lower round pick. He played well in the game.
Saturday, February 14, 2009
Senior Bowl Positional Detail: Defensive Line
North Squad:
1. B.J. Raji, 6-01.5, 334 lbs.- Great decision of his to show up and dominate with authority to show that he's an elite prospect. Nobody could block him.
2. Ron Brace, 6-03.0, 329 lbs.- I love how he attacks his blocker. He'll never be a great pass rusher, but he'll be a necessary cog in any defensive line.
3. Ziggy Hood, 6-03.1, 298 lbs.- He'll have to show he's got more than the spin move he showed at the Senior Bowl. He wasn't blocked while he was there, but there isn't as much room in the NFL. He has a chance to be a Darnell Dockett-type.
4. Will Davis, 6-02.3, 262 lbs.- He showed some pass rush ability, but he's not a top prospect. Likely a mid rounder type.
5. Larry English, 6-02.1, 254 lbs.- Doesn't have the size yet to be an every down DE. He has great explosion off the edge, but for now he's a one trick pony. He'd be fantastic as a 3-4 OLB.
6. Cody Brown, 6-02.1, 242 lbs.- He's likely to be a 3-4 OLB, and has good pass rush ability. He's also solid against the run.
7. Tim Jamison, 6-02.5, 265 lbs.- He has ok size, and is pretty good against the run. He shows flashes, but not enough to be highly regarded. He's a mid round candidate.
8. Mitch King, 6-01.4, 275 lbs.- The guards couldn't block him on the inside, and that might be his calling card; as a situational DT pass rusher. He's too short for the outside.
South Squad:
1. Fili Moala, 6-04.2, 303 lbs.- He's got the ability to be pretty versatile, and can play alot of positions. He's a strong 2nd round posibility. He had a good, not great, Senior Bowl week.
2. Corey Irvin, 6-03.0, 296 lbs.- He flashed at times, and showed that he's a legit mid round prospect.
3. Peria Jerry, 6-01.5, 290 lbs.- He's a tad undersized, but like the "whirling dervish" Z.Hood, he's got exceptional quickness inside, and can run sideline to sideline. Late first, early second is where he'll likely go.
4. Vance Walker, 6-02.0, 295 lbs.- Good size, not great. He's likely a backup, and a mid rounder. There are a lot of players like him in this draft.
5. Kyle Moore, 6-04.6, 264 lbs.- Very good size, and could play alot of positions in the NFL. His versatility will likely knock him up a notch, and he could go in the second round.
6. Robert Ayers, 6-03.1, 273 lbs.- His stock is soaring, and rightfully so. He can really rush the passer, and might be a steal if he goes too late in the first round.
7. David Veikune, 6-02.2, 255 lbs.- He reminds me of Tedi Bruschi in a way. He could be the type that plays alot of positions, and has some versatility to him. I don't think he'll be a lineman, I see him more as an OLB, even a MLB.
8. Lawrence Sidbury, 6-02.3, 267 lbs.- He's got some ability, but he's probably going to have to develop some. He did a good job at both the Sr Bowl, and EW Shrine game. Middle rounder.
1. B.J. Raji, 6-01.5, 334 lbs.- Great decision of his to show up and dominate with authority to show that he's an elite prospect. Nobody could block him.
2. Ron Brace, 6-03.0, 329 lbs.- I love how he attacks his blocker. He'll never be a great pass rusher, but he'll be a necessary cog in any defensive line.
3. Ziggy Hood, 6-03.1, 298 lbs.- He'll have to show he's got more than the spin move he showed at the Senior Bowl. He wasn't blocked while he was there, but there isn't as much room in the NFL. He has a chance to be a Darnell Dockett-type.
4. Will Davis, 6-02.3, 262 lbs.- He showed some pass rush ability, but he's not a top prospect. Likely a mid rounder type.
5. Larry English, 6-02.1, 254 lbs.- Doesn't have the size yet to be an every down DE. He has great explosion off the edge, but for now he's a one trick pony. He'd be fantastic as a 3-4 OLB.
6. Cody Brown, 6-02.1, 242 lbs.- He's likely to be a 3-4 OLB, and has good pass rush ability. He's also solid against the run.
7. Tim Jamison, 6-02.5, 265 lbs.- He has ok size, and is pretty good against the run. He shows flashes, but not enough to be highly regarded. He's a mid round candidate.
8. Mitch King, 6-01.4, 275 lbs.- The guards couldn't block him on the inside, and that might be his calling card; as a situational DT pass rusher. He's too short for the outside.
South Squad:
1. Fili Moala, 6-04.2, 303 lbs.- He's got the ability to be pretty versatile, and can play alot of positions. He's a strong 2nd round posibility. He had a good, not great, Senior Bowl week.
2. Corey Irvin, 6-03.0, 296 lbs.- He flashed at times, and showed that he's a legit mid round prospect.
3. Peria Jerry, 6-01.5, 290 lbs.- He's a tad undersized, but like the "whirling dervish" Z.Hood, he's got exceptional quickness inside, and can run sideline to sideline. Late first, early second is where he'll likely go.
4. Vance Walker, 6-02.0, 295 lbs.- Good size, not great. He's likely a backup, and a mid rounder. There are a lot of players like him in this draft.
5. Kyle Moore, 6-04.6, 264 lbs.- Very good size, and could play alot of positions in the NFL. His versatility will likely knock him up a notch, and he could go in the second round.
6. Robert Ayers, 6-03.1, 273 lbs.- His stock is soaring, and rightfully so. He can really rush the passer, and might be a steal if he goes too late in the first round.
7. David Veikune, 6-02.2, 255 lbs.- He reminds me of Tedi Bruschi in a way. He could be the type that plays alot of positions, and has some versatility to him. I don't think he'll be a lineman, I see him more as an OLB, even a MLB.
8. Lawrence Sidbury, 6-02.3, 267 lbs.- He's got some ability, but he's probably going to have to develop some. He did a good job at both the Sr Bowl, and EW Shrine game. Middle rounder.
Senior Bowl Positional Detail: RB's
North Squad:
1. Kory Sheets, 5-11.1, 203 lbs.- Sheets doesn't have great size but showed a decent burst in practice.
2. Jeremiah Johnson, 5-08.6, 198 lbs.- Johnson shows some quicks, but isn't an every down back. Maybe a third down back.
3. Cedric Peerman, 5-09.3, 210 lbs.- Peerman showed some flashes, and could surprise with his production in the NFL. Sleeper candidate.
4. Eric Kettani, 5-11.5, 231 lbs.- OK prospect, but his Navy status makes it difficult to see him being drafted. More of a FB type, anyways.
5. Tony Fiametta, 5-11.7, 246 lbs.- Pretty decent FB prospect, with some OK hands. Is a late round/FA fodder type who could make a roster.
South Squad:
1. James Davis, 5-10.6, 207 lbs.- Didn't show a burst, was pretty disappointed with his play all week. Did not stand out.
2. Rashad Jennings, 6-01.0, 234 lbs.- Came in with a rep, left with a whimper. He didn't show a burst, either. Will need to gather more info.
3. Andre Brown, 6-00.2, 224 lbs.- The star of the RB's at the Sr. Bowl. Showed that he's got some upside.
4. Arian Foster, 6-00.4, 232 lbs.- Not exactly light on his feet, but has some movement as well. He could surprise.
5. Quinn Johnson, 6-00.6, 251 lbs.- Great size, and good feet. Definitely the superior FB prospect. Good blocker.
1. Kory Sheets, 5-11.1, 203 lbs.- Sheets doesn't have great size but showed a decent burst in practice.
2. Jeremiah Johnson, 5-08.6, 198 lbs.- Johnson shows some quicks, but isn't an every down back. Maybe a third down back.
3. Cedric Peerman, 5-09.3, 210 lbs.- Peerman showed some flashes, and could surprise with his production in the NFL. Sleeper candidate.
4. Eric Kettani, 5-11.5, 231 lbs.- OK prospect, but his Navy status makes it difficult to see him being drafted. More of a FB type, anyways.
5. Tony Fiametta, 5-11.7, 246 lbs.- Pretty decent FB prospect, with some OK hands. Is a late round/FA fodder type who could make a roster.
South Squad:
1. James Davis, 5-10.6, 207 lbs.- Didn't show a burst, was pretty disappointed with his play all week. Did not stand out.
2. Rashad Jennings, 6-01.0, 234 lbs.- Came in with a rep, left with a whimper. He didn't show a burst, either. Will need to gather more info.
3. Andre Brown, 6-00.2, 224 lbs.- The star of the RB's at the Sr. Bowl. Showed that he's got some upside.
4. Arian Foster, 6-00.4, 232 lbs.- Not exactly light on his feet, but has some movement as well. He could surprise.
5. Quinn Johnson, 6-00.6, 251 lbs.- Great size, and good feet. Definitely the superior FB prospect. Good blocker.
Sunday, February 8, 2009
Senior Bowl Positional Detail: Offensive Tackles
North Squad:
1. William Beatty, 6-06.0, 291 lbs.- He had a great week, and is moving up my list because of it. He has great feet and a great wingspan. He also has a frame where he can easily put on 20 lbs. He's a great prospect.
2. Xavier Fulton, 6-04.4, 301 lbs.- He struggled with movement, he didn't have a great week. I think he needs to move inside, and play left guard. He's a mid to late round guy.
3. Phil Loadholt, 6-08.0, 343 lbs.- What you see is what you get with him. He proved at the Sr. Bowl that he is strictly a RT, but I think he's a starter in this league. He's a cab ride to get around, and he can mash, although speed rushers do give him fits.
South Squad:
1. Michael Oher, 6-05.0, 309 lbs.- Although he was a little inconsistant with the one-on-ones, Oher did impress enough this week to retain his first round status. He did prove, however, that he's not an elite prospect; he has work to do. He does play too high at times, which is correctable. Otherwise, he's pretty sound, and will be a good, not great, player.
2. Troy Kropog, 6-05.3, 316 lbs.- He had a pretty good week, and is moving up draft boards. He should go in either round 2 or three, but he's more of a zone blocker, and should do well in that scheme. He reminds me of those NE blockers they churn out of the factory.
3. Jason Watkins, 6-06.0, 317 lbs.- He had a decent week, but showed better during the game. He might be a little bit under the radar right now, someone might get him in the third or fourth and get a guy who might start. Watch out for him at the combine.
1. William Beatty, 6-06.0, 291 lbs.- He had a great week, and is moving up my list because of it. He has great feet and a great wingspan. He also has a frame where he can easily put on 20 lbs. He's a great prospect.
2. Xavier Fulton, 6-04.4, 301 lbs.- He struggled with movement, he didn't have a great week. I think he needs to move inside, and play left guard. He's a mid to late round guy.
3. Phil Loadholt, 6-08.0, 343 lbs.- What you see is what you get with him. He proved at the Sr. Bowl that he is strictly a RT, but I think he's a starter in this league. He's a cab ride to get around, and he can mash, although speed rushers do give him fits.
South Squad:
1. Michael Oher, 6-05.0, 309 lbs.- Although he was a little inconsistant with the one-on-ones, Oher did impress enough this week to retain his first round status. He did prove, however, that he's not an elite prospect; he has work to do. He does play too high at times, which is correctable. Otherwise, he's pretty sound, and will be a good, not great, player.
2. Troy Kropog, 6-05.3, 316 lbs.- He had a pretty good week, and is moving up draft boards. He should go in either round 2 or three, but he's more of a zone blocker, and should do well in that scheme. He reminds me of those NE blockers they churn out of the factory.
3. Jason Watkins, 6-06.0, 317 lbs.- He had a decent week, but showed better during the game. He might be a little bit under the radar right now, someone might get him in the third or fourth and get a guy who might start. Watch out for him at the combine.
Friday, February 6, 2009
Senior Bowl Positional Detail: Guards
North Squad:
1. Kraig Urbik, 6-05.3, 323 lbs.- Urbik was one of my favorites. You would see him smiling while he was playing physical. That's his style. He is limited to phone booth type of stuff, but the smaller the space for him, the better. He's also strictly a right guard, so he has to start to carry value.
2. Andy Levitre, 6-02.3, 306 lbs.- He's sort of a tweener, and needs to become more versatile. He struggled when he had to move his feet, which was sort of his forte. He's more of a puller/trapper, so he's got to go to the right team.
3. Trevor Canfield, 6-04.4, 311 lbs.- He did well at times, but is still just a late round guy. He had trouble moving his feet when times were tough, which was the norm for most of the blockers.
South Squad:
1. Tyronne Green, 6-01.5, 305 lbs.- He moves his feet well, and has a little bit of a streak going for him. He put in a solid week, although the south didn't have the defensive tackles that the north team had to deal with.
2. Anthony Parker, 6-01.7, 310 lbs.- He looked the smoothest of the natural guards, which isn't saying much, since there wasn't a strong class. Some of the centers will move to guard, but I think Parker can start on Sundays.
3. Herman Johnson, 6-07.3, 382 lbs.- He looked out of place, he doesn't belong in this atmosphere. Who invited him? He's big, but so am I. I wouldn't have him on my board, he's not at all an athlete. I don't think he can move within a phone booth, let alone deal with someone who can move a little.
1. Kraig Urbik, 6-05.3, 323 lbs.- Urbik was one of my favorites. You would see him smiling while he was playing physical. That's his style. He is limited to phone booth type of stuff, but the smaller the space for him, the better. He's also strictly a right guard, so he has to start to carry value.
2. Andy Levitre, 6-02.3, 306 lbs.- He's sort of a tweener, and needs to become more versatile. He struggled when he had to move his feet, which was sort of his forte. He's more of a puller/trapper, so he's got to go to the right team.
3. Trevor Canfield, 6-04.4, 311 lbs.- He did well at times, but is still just a late round guy. He had trouble moving his feet when times were tough, which was the norm for most of the blockers.
South Squad:
1. Tyronne Green, 6-01.5, 305 lbs.- He moves his feet well, and has a little bit of a streak going for him. He put in a solid week, although the south didn't have the defensive tackles that the north team had to deal with.
2. Anthony Parker, 6-01.7, 310 lbs.- He looked the smoothest of the natural guards, which isn't saying much, since there wasn't a strong class. Some of the centers will move to guard, but I think Parker can start on Sundays.
3. Herman Johnson, 6-07.3, 382 lbs.- He looked out of place, he doesn't belong in this atmosphere. Who invited him? He's big, but so am I. I wouldn't have him on my board, he's not at all an athlete. I don't think he can move within a phone booth, let alone deal with someone who can move a little.
Thursday, February 5, 2009
Tigers tidbits...
1. Justin Verlander just agreed to a one year deal for 2009, avoiding arbitration. The Tigers have done a great job in avoiding arbitration since Dombrowski has taken over. I don't see him wanting a long term deal until he becomes a free agent after the 2011 season. If the Tigers are considering trading anyone with a high return, next year might be the time with Verlander if he isn't signed long term. Stay tuned.
2. Rick Knapp is a great choice for pitching coach, bringing over the Twins organizational philosophies of command over velocity and movement. The signing of Brandon Lyon falls in place with this philosophy, and the Tigers need to keep this up. I also disagree that Armando Gallarraga should be in any trouble to make the team this year. He was very efficient, and very effective as a starter, and the Tigers need his consistancy. No amount of what Dontrelle Willis brings in the spring would convince me that he and Nate Robinson should be in the rotation.
2. Rick Knapp is a great choice for pitching coach, bringing over the Twins organizational philosophies of command over velocity and movement. The signing of Brandon Lyon falls in place with this philosophy, and the Tigers need to keep this up. I also disagree that Armando Gallarraga should be in any trouble to make the team this year. He was very efficient, and very effective as a starter, and the Tigers need his consistancy. No amount of what Dontrelle Willis brings in the spring would convince me that he and Nate Robinson should be in the rotation.
Friday, January 23, 2009
Senior Bowl Positional Detail: Center
North Squad
Alex Mack; 6-04.1, 312: Mack has been extremely solid at the practices, and shows a nice upside in the pivot. He's had some minor struggles with BJ Raji, but everybody has. He has great size, and should be a solid 2nd rounder.
Max Unger; 6-04.6, 299: Unger has struggled as much as anybody else, especially with snaps that must be addressed. Blocking wise he's been ok, but I'd like to see him at different positions.
Ryan Shuman; 6-02.6, 300: Shuman has battled as much as possible, but he's not athletic enough to start in the NFL.
South Squad
Antoine Caldwell; 6-03.3, 307: He's a bit of a pit bull, and gets very low. He anchors very well, and sets his feet. He's got the best feet of the centers.
Eric Wood; 6-04.1, 304: He hasn't disappointed. He's one of my favorites, and is quite a battler. The line play this year has been extremely impressive, and he's standing out.
Jonathon Luigs; 6-03.3, 302: He's been very solid, as the South centers have dominated the line play this week.
Alex Mack; 6-04.1, 312: Mack has been extremely solid at the practices, and shows a nice upside in the pivot. He's had some minor struggles with BJ Raji, but everybody has. He has great size, and should be a solid 2nd rounder.
Max Unger; 6-04.6, 299: Unger has struggled as much as anybody else, especially with snaps that must be addressed. Blocking wise he's been ok, but I'd like to see him at different positions.
Ryan Shuman; 6-02.6, 300: Shuman has battled as much as possible, but he's not athletic enough to start in the NFL.
South Squad
Antoine Caldwell; 6-03.3, 307: He's a bit of a pit bull, and gets very low. He anchors very well, and sets his feet. He's got the best feet of the centers.
Eric Wood; 6-04.1, 304: He hasn't disappointed. He's one of my favorites, and is quite a battler. The line play this year has been extremely impressive, and he's standing out.
Jonathon Luigs; 6-03.3, 302: He's been very solid, as the South centers have dominated the line play this week.
Thursday, January 22, 2009
Senior Bowl Positional Detail: TE's
North Squad
Connor Barwin; 6-03.3, 253: Can play both DE and TE. That kind of versatility goes a long way. Could be either in the NFL. Solid TE prospect, he's suppose to be better at DE.
John Phillips; 6-05.3, 251: Great size, but not athletic enough. Hasn't caught my eye, will have to wait until combine to get a better read on him.
Brandon Pettigrew; 6-05.1, 257: Great all around player. Doesn't play fast enough, but is good in passing game. Won't stretch the field, but is a great blocker.
South Squad
Shawn Nelson; 6-04.6, 238: He's got very good feet, and has held his own as a blocker. He's looking up, and should be a third round pick.
Travis McCall; 6-02.0, 276: Kind of short, might move to fullback. Inline blocker type.
Anthony Hill; 6-05.1, 264: All-pro body type. Great size, need to see more, probably at combine.
Connor Barwin; 6-03.3, 253: Can play both DE and TE. That kind of versatility goes a long way. Could be either in the NFL. Solid TE prospect, he's suppose to be better at DE.
John Phillips; 6-05.3, 251: Great size, but not athletic enough. Hasn't caught my eye, will have to wait until combine to get a better read on him.
Brandon Pettigrew; 6-05.1, 257: Great all around player. Doesn't play fast enough, but is good in passing game. Won't stretch the field, but is a great blocker.
South Squad
Shawn Nelson; 6-04.6, 238: He's got very good feet, and has held his own as a blocker. He's looking up, and should be a third round pick.
Travis McCall; 6-02.0, 276: Kind of short, might move to fullback. Inline blocker type.
Anthony Hill; 6-05.1, 264: All-pro body type. Great size, need to see more, probably at combine.
Wednesday, January 21, 2009
Senior Bowl Positional Detail: WR
I'll skip the RB's until after the Senior Bowl game, which is the best time to evaluate the RB's.
North Squad:
Brooks Foster; 6-00.5, 204: He's shown a burst for someone who had injury problems and missed his bowl game. According to NFL network he isn't 100% yet, but he's showing great heart and effort. I am eagerly awaiting his time.
Derrick Williams; 5-11.2, 197: He's always been one of my favorite type of players, as he plays with the type of energy that is contagious. He has great burst, but has struggled somewhat with his hands. I wouldn't sell him short, as his short area burst is top in this year's draft class. He's making plays in practice.
Brandon Gibson; 6-00.3, 204: I need to see more of him to get a better feel for him.
Juaquin Iglesias; 6-00.5, 204: I thought he'd be bigger, but he is what he is. He's a solid third round type who will be an extra receiver. He needs to develop to become more.
Ramses Barden; 6-06.0, 227: He has legitimate size, but that might be all he's got going for him. I need to see more, but he's not impressing so far.
Brian Robiskie; 6-02.7, 207: I think he's always been sold short, but he's a great route runner, and should take less time to develop. He's the type who could start in the NFL right away, not many WR's can do that. I think he's underrated, and should be a high second rounder.
South Squad:
Mo Massaquoi; 6-01.3, 210: He's had the case of the dropsies in practice, which is his rep. I think he's average, and is overrated. He's also a tad shorter than I thought he'd be.
Mike Thomas; 5-08.0, 187: Don't let his size fool you, he's a rat, and a tough receiver. He has a little bit of Steve Smith in him, but I don't know if he can handle the deep routes like Smith. Right now he's great underneath, and has very good hands. He's a receiver's receiver.
Quan Cosby; 5-08.6, 191: He's more of the possession type, and I don't see too much of an upside. He's got decent hands, and looks like a decent mid round pick. He's experienced, and is close to a finished product.
Patrick Turner; 6-05.1, 221: I don't believe he's in Mobile, or I'm completely missing him.
Mike Wallace; 6-00.1, 189: Unheralded receiver who was a key cog in college defense. He's got some quicks to him, and I believe he's running under the radar right now. Watch out for him. I need to see him run.
Kenny McKinley; 5-11.5, 182: Is struggling in his limited reps in Mobile. Had QB problems at SC, so it's tough to get a guage on him.
North Squad:
Brooks Foster; 6-00.5, 204: He's shown a burst for someone who had injury problems and missed his bowl game. According to NFL network he isn't 100% yet, but he's showing great heart and effort. I am eagerly awaiting his time.
Derrick Williams; 5-11.2, 197: He's always been one of my favorite type of players, as he plays with the type of energy that is contagious. He has great burst, but has struggled somewhat with his hands. I wouldn't sell him short, as his short area burst is top in this year's draft class. He's making plays in practice.
Brandon Gibson; 6-00.3, 204: I need to see more of him to get a better feel for him.
Juaquin Iglesias; 6-00.5, 204: I thought he'd be bigger, but he is what he is. He's a solid third round type who will be an extra receiver. He needs to develop to become more.
Ramses Barden; 6-06.0, 227: He has legitimate size, but that might be all he's got going for him. I need to see more, but he's not impressing so far.
Brian Robiskie; 6-02.7, 207: I think he's always been sold short, but he's a great route runner, and should take less time to develop. He's the type who could start in the NFL right away, not many WR's can do that. I think he's underrated, and should be a high second rounder.
South Squad:
Mo Massaquoi; 6-01.3, 210: He's had the case of the dropsies in practice, which is his rep. I think he's average, and is overrated. He's also a tad shorter than I thought he'd be.
Mike Thomas; 5-08.0, 187: Don't let his size fool you, he's a rat, and a tough receiver. He has a little bit of Steve Smith in him, but I don't know if he can handle the deep routes like Smith. Right now he's great underneath, and has very good hands. He's a receiver's receiver.
Quan Cosby; 5-08.6, 191: He's more of the possession type, and I don't see too much of an upside. He's got decent hands, and looks like a decent mid round pick. He's experienced, and is close to a finished product.
Patrick Turner; 6-05.1, 221: I don't believe he's in Mobile, or I'm completely missing him.
Mike Wallace; 6-00.1, 189: Unheralded receiver who was a key cog in college defense. He's got some quicks to him, and I believe he's running under the radar right now. Watch out for him. I need to see him run.
Kenny McKinley; 5-11.5, 182: Is struggling in his limited reps in Mobile. Had QB problems at SC, so it's tough to get a guage on him.
Senior Bowl Positional Detail: QB
Thanks to Great Blue North for the measurements...
North Squad:
Graham Harrell; 6-02.0, 217: Harrell has caught my eye, as he definitely looks prepared to take snaps from center. He has been extremely accurate, but hasn't had to make too difficult of a throw yet. I know he can throw the deep ball, I need to know if he has enough arm to make all the necessary throws. His stock is rising, and he's a safe bet to go in either the second or third round. Another thing I like about Harrell is that he makes his decisions quickly, and gets the ball out fast. He's not quick, but knows where to go, and when to step up in the pocket.
Rhett Bomar; 6-02.1, 224: He's been inconsistant with his arm slot, as he drops down to a three quarter delivery at times which compromises his strong arm. He's physically talented, but struggles with his mechanics, and shows indecisiveness in the pocket. He's a late round project, and I don't know if he's worth the trouble.
Nathan Brown; 6-00.5, 217: He's a developmental project with limited upside. He has decent accuracy and arm strength, but is limited due to a lack of height and limited reps. He looks like a small school QB.
South Squad:
Cullen Harper; 6-02.6, 227: He's had a rough year, as a coaching change and shoulder injury has squandered this once highly thought of prospect. He threw for more INT's than TD's, which is not forgivable. He is probably limited to UDFA at this time.
John Parker Wilson; 6-01.4, 215: He doesn't have alot of natural skills, but has been a mudder who gets the job done. He might be a late round pick, and may make a team as a third option if the stars align for him. He's looked solid in practice, but he's always had an issue with holding onto the ball too long.
Pat White; 6-00.0, 190: He knows what he is, and that is a highly talented player who teams need to find a place for in the NFL. He makes the quintessential slash type of player, who can play many positions and cause a great deal of matchup problems for a defense. He's also shown surprising accuracy down at Mobile.
North Squad:
Graham Harrell; 6-02.0, 217: Harrell has caught my eye, as he definitely looks prepared to take snaps from center. He has been extremely accurate, but hasn't had to make too difficult of a throw yet. I know he can throw the deep ball, I need to know if he has enough arm to make all the necessary throws. His stock is rising, and he's a safe bet to go in either the second or third round. Another thing I like about Harrell is that he makes his decisions quickly, and gets the ball out fast. He's not quick, but knows where to go, and when to step up in the pocket.
Rhett Bomar; 6-02.1, 224: He's been inconsistant with his arm slot, as he drops down to a three quarter delivery at times which compromises his strong arm. He's physically talented, but struggles with his mechanics, and shows indecisiveness in the pocket. He's a late round project, and I don't know if he's worth the trouble.
Nathan Brown; 6-00.5, 217: He's a developmental project with limited upside. He has decent accuracy and arm strength, but is limited due to a lack of height and limited reps. He looks like a small school QB.
South Squad:
Cullen Harper; 6-02.6, 227: He's had a rough year, as a coaching change and shoulder injury has squandered this once highly thought of prospect. He threw for more INT's than TD's, which is not forgivable. He is probably limited to UDFA at this time.
John Parker Wilson; 6-01.4, 215: He doesn't have alot of natural skills, but has been a mudder who gets the job done. He might be a late round pick, and may make a team as a third option if the stars align for him. He's looked solid in practice, but he's always had an issue with holding onto the ball too long.
Pat White; 6-00.0, 190: He knows what he is, and that is a highly talented player who teams need to find a place for in the NFL. He makes the quintessential slash type of player, who can play many positions and cause a great deal of matchup problems for a defense. He's also shown surprising accuracy down at Mobile.
Thursday, January 15, 2009
My top 5 at each position...
QB
1. Matt Stafford
2. Mark Sanchez
3. Josh Freeman
4. Graham Harrell
5. Nate Davis
I love Matt Stafford, I think he's the perfect fit for the Lions at #1. I think Mark Sanchez is a good game manager, ala Matt Leinart (who hasn't been the manager in the NFL). Freeman has physical ability and size, although he lacks accuracy and consistancy. Harrell I like his presence in the pocket, although questions will linger about being a system QB. I like Nate Davis, but he's rough.
RB
1. Chris Wells
2. Knowshown Moreno
3. Lesean McCoy
4. James Davis
5. Shonn Greene
Chris Wells is headed to the top 10 as a power runner, although RB's do slip. Moreno needs to run well, but has terrific athleticism, and should garner first round grades; although it's possible he'll fall with McCoy to the 2nd round. I think Greene is a special case, and might have the best game for the next level. He runs with great leverage, and plays fast. He'll be a bargain with his advanced age. I also love Glen Coffey, who's a gamebreaker himself.
WR
1. Michael Crabtree
2. Jeremy Maclin
3. Hakeem Nicks
4. Kenny Britt
5. Darrius Heyward-Bey
There is actually some depth at this position now, with an exceptional load of underclassmen joining the ranks. Crabtree needs to run well, but should still go high-1. Maclin is a multi-faceted burner, and Nicks has great hands. I love Britt and Bey's upside.
TE
1. Brandon Pettigrew
2. Chase Coffman
3. Jared Cook
4. Travis Beckum
5. Dennis Pitta
Pettigrew is a stud, and should go somewhere in the mid-late first. Coffman is a solid player, and should be a predictably handy pass catching TE at the NFL level. Cook has physical tools, although his performances have been up and down. He could get a late push for his talents, but buyer beware. Beckum is coming off the broken leg, but would have been a first day pick before his injury. I'd love to see Pitta run a 40 before I'd assess a final grade. This is a good class, but it could have been a great class with Gresham.
OT
1. Andre Smith
2. Michael Oher
3. Eugene Monroe
4. Jason Smith
5. Phil Loadholt
I concede Smith will go high one, but there's alot that I remain weary about him. He scares me on an island, and he had TE help on his side at Alabama. I've knocked Oher, but he's a good football player. Probably a top 10 pick. Monroe and Smith are very similar, and they are two experienced and dependable blockers. I'm higher on Loadholt than others are. He reminds me of Marcus McNeill of the Chargers, and he might be able to stay on the left side.
OG
1. Duke Robinson
2. Sergio Render
3. Herman Johnson
4. Kraig Urbik
5. Anthony Parker
Ugh, Duke! When he's in control, he's a top of the line blocker, but he commits too many penalties for my liking, although technically I have to put him at the top. I like Render more than Johnson, but maybe Johnson is out of position...RT anyone? Urbik is a battler, and Parker has good feet.
C
1. Max Unger
2. Alex Mack
3. Jonathon Luigs
4. Eric Wood
5. A.Q. Shipley
Mack is getting some hype, but Unger has more value, as he can play almost anywhere on the line of scrimmage. The rest including Cooper, are very good centers. This is the best class of centers I can remember...
DE
1. Everette Brown
2. Brian Orakpo
3. Aaron Maybin
4. Tyson Jackson
5. Michael Johnson
This is a really solid group of pass rushers. I like Brown over Orakpo, simply because I think he's more physical at the point of attack, and he reminds me of Andre Carter. Orakpo has great burst, but bursts his way out of too many plays. Jackson is a better run defender, and Maybin is a 3-4 OLB rush end waiting to happen. Johnson is more for show than go.
DT
1. BJ Raji
2. Peria Jerry
3. SenDerrick Marks
4. Fili Moala
5. Ron Brace
I love the team of Raji/Brace so much, and I think Brace is underrated because of Raji. Raji is lurking, but I think the NFL will catch up to him. He's really a superstar, and might be a top 10 (maybe higher) pick before it's all said and done. Jerry and Marks are strictly three techniques, although Moala offers some versatility in the roles he plays. This isn't a strong class, but these are five good players.
OLB
1. Aaron Curry
2. Brian Cushing
3. Clay Mathews
4. Clint Sintim
5. Marcus Freeman
Curry is a stud, although it looks like he has free reign within the WF defensive scheme. He's all over the place, and doesn't look out of place rushing the passer with his hand down. He reminds me of Junior Seau, but bigger. The rest of the guys are all similar...they're pretty safe bets to be solid players at the next level. All three USC LB's could go in the first round, which is impressive.
ILB
1. Rey Maulauga
2. James Laurinaitis
3. Dannell Ellerbe
4. Jasper Brinkley
5. Scott McKillop
I'm not convinced 100% that Laurinaitis isn't the better MLB, but this is a conservative ranking. When I key in on Laurinaitis, he's making great reads, moves well, and has great functional strength, as he showed against Texas. I think McKillop doesn't get enough hype, as he is a better player than given credit for.
CB
1. Vontae Davis
2. Malcolm Jenkins
3. DJ Moore
4. Alphonso Smith
5. Asher Allen
I think Davis is terrific, and I also wonder how fast Jenkins is. We'll know more after they run. I love Moore's toughness, and Smith is a terrific player.
S
1. Rashad Johnson
2. Nic Harris
3. William Moore
4. Louis Delmas
5. Patrick Chung
I've gone back and forth with this safety class, wondering what to think about it. I'm kind of meh about them as a group, although there is something there. I like Harris as a hitter, and I think he should be a SS in the box type. Delmas is getting too much hype, that I'm not buying. He's a nice 2nd rounder, maybe third.
1. Matt Stafford
2. Mark Sanchez
3. Josh Freeman
4. Graham Harrell
5. Nate Davis
I love Matt Stafford, I think he's the perfect fit for the Lions at #1. I think Mark Sanchez is a good game manager, ala Matt Leinart (who hasn't been the manager in the NFL). Freeman has physical ability and size, although he lacks accuracy and consistancy. Harrell I like his presence in the pocket, although questions will linger about being a system QB. I like Nate Davis, but he's rough.
RB
1. Chris Wells
2. Knowshown Moreno
3. Lesean McCoy
4. James Davis
5. Shonn Greene
Chris Wells is headed to the top 10 as a power runner, although RB's do slip. Moreno needs to run well, but has terrific athleticism, and should garner first round grades; although it's possible he'll fall with McCoy to the 2nd round. I think Greene is a special case, and might have the best game for the next level. He runs with great leverage, and plays fast. He'll be a bargain with his advanced age. I also love Glen Coffey, who's a gamebreaker himself.
WR
1. Michael Crabtree
2. Jeremy Maclin
3. Hakeem Nicks
4. Kenny Britt
5. Darrius Heyward-Bey
There is actually some depth at this position now, with an exceptional load of underclassmen joining the ranks. Crabtree needs to run well, but should still go high-1. Maclin is a multi-faceted burner, and Nicks has great hands. I love Britt and Bey's upside.
TE
1. Brandon Pettigrew
2. Chase Coffman
3. Jared Cook
4. Travis Beckum
5. Dennis Pitta
Pettigrew is a stud, and should go somewhere in the mid-late first. Coffman is a solid player, and should be a predictably handy pass catching TE at the NFL level. Cook has physical tools, although his performances have been up and down. He could get a late push for his talents, but buyer beware. Beckum is coming off the broken leg, but would have been a first day pick before his injury. I'd love to see Pitta run a 40 before I'd assess a final grade. This is a good class, but it could have been a great class with Gresham.
OT
1. Andre Smith
2. Michael Oher
3. Eugene Monroe
4. Jason Smith
5. Phil Loadholt
I concede Smith will go high one, but there's alot that I remain weary about him. He scares me on an island, and he had TE help on his side at Alabama. I've knocked Oher, but he's a good football player. Probably a top 10 pick. Monroe and Smith are very similar, and they are two experienced and dependable blockers. I'm higher on Loadholt than others are. He reminds me of Marcus McNeill of the Chargers, and he might be able to stay on the left side.
OG
1. Duke Robinson
2. Sergio Render
3. Herman Johnson
4. Kraig Urbik
5. Anthony Parker
Ugh, Duke! When he's in control, he's a top of the line blocker, but he commits too many penalties for my liking, although technically I have to put him at the top. I like Render more than Johnson, but maybe Johnson is out of position...RT anyone? Urbik is a battler, and Parker has good feet.
C
1. Max Unger
2. Alex Mack
3. Jonathon Luigs
4. Eric Wood
5. A.Q. Shipley
Mack is getting some hype, but Unger has more value, as he can play almost anywhere on the line of scrimmage. The rest including Cooper, are very good centers. This is the best class of centers I can remember...
DE
1. Everette Brown
2. Brian Orakpo
3. Aaron Maybin
4. Tyson Jackson
5. Michael Johnson
This is a really solid group of pass rushers. I like Brown over Orakpo, simply because I think he's more physical at the point of attack, and he reminds me of Andre Carter. Orakpo has great burst, but bursts his way out of too many plays. Jackson is a better run defender, and Maybin is a 3-4 OLB rush end waiting to happen. Johnson is more for show than go.
DT
1. BJ Raji
2. Peria Jerry
3. SenDerrick Marks
4. Fili Moala
5. Ron Brace
I love the team of Raji/Brace so much, and I think Brace is underrated because of Raji. Raji is lurking, but I think the NFL will catch up to him. He's really a superstar, and might be a top 10 (maybe higher) pick before it's all said and done. Jerry and Marks are strictly three techniques, although Moala offers some versatility in the roles he plays. This isn't a strong class, but these are five good players.
OLB
1. Aaron Curry
2. Brian Cushing
3. Clay Mathews
4. Clint Sintim
5. Marcus Freeman
Curry is a stud, although it looks like he has free reign within the WF defensive scheme. He's all over the place, and doesn't look out of place rushing the passer with his hand down. He reminds me of Junior Seau, but bigger. The rest of the guys are all similar...they're pretty safe bets to be solid players at the next level. All three USC LB's could go in the first round, which is impressive.
ILB
1. Rey Maulauga
2. James Laurinaitis
3. Dannell Ellerbe
4. Jasper Brinkley
5. Scott McKillop
I'm not convinced 100% that Laurinaitis isn't the better MLB, but this is a conservative ranking. When I key in on Laurinaitis, he's making great reads, moves well, and has great functional strength, as he showed against Texas. I think McKillop doesn't get enough hype, as he is a better player than given credit for.
CB
1. Vontae Davis
2. Malcolm Jenkins
3. DJ Moore
4. Alphonso Smith
5. Asher Allen
I think Davis is terrific, and I also wonder how fast Jenkins is. We'll know more after they run. I love Moore's toughness, and Smith is a terrific player.
S
1. Rashad Johnson
2. Nic Harris
3. William Moore
4. Louis Delmas
5. Patrick Chung
I've gone back and forth with this safety class, wondering what to think about it. I'm kind of meh about them as a group, although there is something there. I like Harris as a hitter, and I think he should be a SS in the box type. Delmas is getting too much hype, that I'm not buying. He's a nice 2nd rounder, maybe third.
Thursday, January 8, 2009
My letter to Wojo...
Regarding his column today in The Detroit News...
Wojo:
I get your point on your article, but the larger question must be...who's the best player? I believe strongly that these two QB's (Stafford and Bradford) are by far the class of this draft, and Stafford should be drafted #1. If you were to pass on a better player to take a "safer" player, isn't that a riskier pick? I have a littany of issues with Andre Smith, considered by most to be one of the top three players. If every play was a run play, he'd be a perfect guy, he's that good against the run. But if you've noticed one thing about Alabama, is that they play the TE to his side to help him in pass protection. He's inconsistant in pass protection, and the Lions have Jeff Backus, who has played every game in his career. The Lions have issues at guard that need to be addressed (smartly, in free agency and later in the draft), but are fine otherwise on their underrated line (most of the sacks were caused by QB's holding onto the ball too long, and WR's not getting open). If you don't have a franchise QB, do not pass on a franchise QB. And these two players are franchise QB's in my opinion. I disagree that Stafford lacks accuracy or decision making. Actually, he does very well when plays break down, and has shown moxie in the pocket. I'd prefer he also come in as the #2 QB for a year, unless he signs right away and there is no question he should start. Both he and Bradford would be much more talented than any other QB the Lions have ever had.
Thank you,
David Hinkle
http://dave-lionsandtigers.blogspot.com/
Wojo:
I get your point on your article, but the larger question must be...who's the best player? I believe strongly that these two QB's (Stafford and Bradford) are by far the class of this draft, and Stafford should be drafted #1. If you were to pass on a better player to take a "safer" player, isn't that a riskier pick? I have a littany of issues with Andre Smith, considered by most to be one of the top three players. If every play was a run play, he'd be a perfect guy, he's that good against the run. But if you've noticed one thing about Alabama, is that they play the TE to his side to help him in pass protection. He's inconsistant in pass protection, and the Lions have Jeff Backus, who has played every game in his career. The Lions have issues at guard that need to be addressed (smartly, in free agency and later in the draft), but are fine otherwise on their underrated line (most of the sacks were caused by QB's holding onto the ball too long, and WR's not getting open). If you don't have a franchise QB, do not pass on a franchise QB. And these two players are franchise QB's in my opinion. I disagree that Stafford lacks accuracy or decision making. Actually, he does very well when plays break down, and has shown moxie in the pocket. I'd prefer he also come in as the #2 QB for a year, unless he signs right away and there is no question he should start. Both he and Bradford would be much more talented than any other QB the Lions have ever had.
Thank you,
David Hinkle
http://dave-lionsandtigers.blogspot.com/
Wednesday, January 7, 2009
Lions roster set for major overhaul...
Tom Kowalski has an in-depth article about the Lions current roster, and the cuts that could allow the Lions to be up to 39.7 million under the cap when free agency hits. He didn't even bring up Kitna, who would be another 2 million freed up. The point of the article is that the Lions won't (as they mentioned in the GM's press conference) be making headlines in March, but rather in December; so the idea is to get more for their money. They're going to need a great deal of cap money for the draft, with their team record allotment of picks/draft position. They're also going to have to act like an expansion franchise, and build with under the radar type signings, such as the Dolphins heisting of Justin Smiley last year. They're going to have to make themselves bigger and faster and younger. Which isn't easy when you're playing with so much money.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Posts
